The best eyeshadow primers you can buy

By

The best eyeshadow primers you can buy

  • Eyeshadow primer is the secret ingredient to a crease-free eye look that stays in place and lasts all day.
  • Our top pick, Too Faced Shadow Insurance, preps eyelids by creating a smooth and even-toned base that lets shimmer and matte shadows pop.

Eyeshadow primer is the single, most game-changing item I’ve added to my makeup collection over the years. Plenty of product categories simply do not live up to the hype but this is one of the few that does; as a beauty journalist who has tested many of these products, including eyeshadows and eyeshadow primers, I would know.

Eyeshadow primer usually comes in a neutral color and has a slightly tacky finish that allows eyeshadows, be they shimmer or matte, to stick down and stay down. It’s the best way to ensure your smoky eye will not budge — until you want it to, that is.

You can opt for an eye primer that matches your skin tone or choose one in a different shade to add a boost of color beneath powder shadows. There are even some color-free and bright-white options. Different kinds of primer will impact your finished look in different ways, but all of the formulas on this list will prolong and intensify your eyeshadow for hours.

When shopping for an eye primer, make sure you pick something versatile enough to work with most of the shadows in your collection — no one needs to own a dozen eye primers. Our five favorites should help you narrow it down.

Here are the best eyeshadow primers you can buy in 2019:

Keep scrolling to read more details about our top picks.

The best overall

Too Faced

Too Faced Shadow Insurance is the one-size-fits-all primer that you’ll use every day.

If you want one versatile eyeshadow primer that you can use daily, opt for Too Faced Shadow Insurance. This is also what I personally use. It has a slippery, lightweight texture that blends seamlessly into my eyelids without tugging on the delicate skin.

This primer has a light beige color, but as you rub it in, the color mostly disappears (at least on my very pale lids). You only need a very tiny dollop for each eye, so a single 0.35-ounce tube lasts for a long time. While I can’t quite attest to the "waterproof, crease- and fade-proof coverage for up to 24 hours" claim, I can say that this primer keeps my eyeshadow looking so good at the end of the night that I procrastinate washing it off.

I’ve noticed that eyeshadows with matte textures are a bit more difficult to blend in when used on top of this primer because it has such a grippy, tacky finish. But the added intensity and long-lasting vibrancy are worth it. Otherwise, this primer works equally well underneath powder, liquid, and cream shadows.

Too Faced Shadow Insurance comes recommended by editors at Best Products, Total Beauty, Into The Gloss, and Allure, and has a 4.6-star rating on Sephora based on 6,000 customer reviews.

Pros: Lightweight formula, easily blendable, waterproof, fragrance-free, wears up to 24 hours

Cons: Comes in one shade

Buy Too Faced Shadow Insurance from Sephora for $20

The best budget primer

Milani

Milani Eyeshadow Primer performs as well as many other expensive options.

I don’t mind splurging on beauty products when I know they’re truly worth the extra cash. But sometimes you just need a great cheap find, especially on everyday staples. The Milani Eyeshadow Primer is a fantastic under-$10 option. It performs similarly to its pricier counterparts, but it won’t have you wincing as you reach for your wallet.

This primer first came to my attention from watching Emily Noel rave about it on YouTube and I’ve since seen it recommended on Byrdie, Bustle, and Rank and Style. Reviewers have compared its eyeshadow-intensifying powers to those of more expensive cult favorites, like Urban Decay Primer Potion and Smashbox.

The Milani Eyeshadow Primer has a pale-nude base that claims to dry invisibly but keep in mind that it comes in only one shade option. "This stuff keeps my eyeshadow on with no creases or excess oil, and tremendously helps with pigmentation of pressed pigments and makes blending much easier," wrote one Ulta shopper.

Pros: Affordable, long-lasting, creates a smooth canvas for eyeshadows, works on oily lids

Cons: Only one shade

Buy the Milani Eyeshadow Primer from Ulta for $6.99

The best for oily eyelids

Urban Decay

Urban Decay Primer Potion has an ideal texture to lock shadows in place for crease-free application on even the oiliest of eyelids.

When your eyelids are like two oil slicks in the center of your face, getting your glam-shadow look to stay put for more than 20 hours is a mere pipe dream. But Urban Decay Primer Potion can absolutely make long-lasting, Instagram-ready eyeshadow a reality. It’s a thicker texture that sticks down and does not budge. If other eye primers tend to melt off your lids like butter, this one is the answer.

Primer Potion comes in a tube with an elongated doe-foot applicator that makes it easy to cover your entire eye up and to the brow bone in a single swipe. Just make sure you tap around the edges to blend it all the way in, otherwise you’ll see a line of demarcation and it may be harder to cover that area with shadow. But once you get a smooth canvas, your shadow will go on seamlessly and stay on seemingly forever. Seriously, you might have to work a little harder to wash it off.

This primer comes in a few shades — there’s the standard sheer nude option, Fix (a matte beige), Caffeine (deeper matte brown), Sin (pale shimmer), and Eden (redness-canceling matte). The original Primer Potion has a 4.6 Sephora rating based on 6,000 reviews and has been featured by Best Products, Total Beauty, Into The Gloss, and Allure.

Pros: Doe-foot applicator, various shade options, good for oily lids, cruelty-free

Cons: Have to blend quickly because once it dries down, it doesn’t budge

Buy Urban Decay Primer Potion from Sephora for $24

See the rest of the story at Business Insider

See Also:

SEE ALSO: The best glitter eyeshadows you can buy

SEE ALSO: The best liquid eyeshadows you can buy

Source: Business Insider – mgokey@businessinsider.com (Erin Mayer)

MustHaves.LA a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.